Home Depot Missed Earnings Again. But Wall Street's $429 Price Target Ignores the Real Risk in Your ETF Portfolio

When does an earnings "miss" become a pattern? 

Home Depot just posted its Q3 straight disappointment. 

But the real risk isn't showing up in headlines yet.

Home Depot's $HD Q3 2025 results delivered exactly what investors feared: Q3 2025 miss, steeper profit guidance cuts, and zero evidence that housing market conditions will improve before mid-2026. 

The market reacted predictably, shares dropped 2-3% pre-market, but the real story isn't the headline EPS miss. It's what the underlying transaction data reveals about consumer behavior and what that means for your broader equity exposure.

Adjusted EPS came in at $3.74, missing $3.84 estimates. 

Revenue rose 2.8% to $41.35 billion, slightly beating estimates, but that top-line beat is misleading.

Strip out the $900 million contribution from the GMS acquisition, and organic growth essentially flatlined. Comparable sales increased just 0.2% globally, with US comps up a negligible 0.1%, far below the 1.3% growth Wall Street expected.

But here's the critical data point most analysts buried: customer transactions fell 1.4%. 

Average ticket size rose to $90.39 from $88.65, but that's not a demand signal, it's inflation and a shift toward larger professional contractor projects. Retail consumer traffic is contracting. 

Management's revised full-year guidance now projects adjusted EPS to decline roughly 5% from 2024's $15.24 baseline. That's a meaningful deterioration from the 2% decline previously forecast. 

Comparable sales growth for the year is now expected to be "slightly positive," down from the earlier 1% target. Translation: Home Depot is managing expectations lower because the demand recovery they anticipated in Q4 isn't materializing.

CEO Ted Decker pointed to three primary headwinds: weaker-than-expected consumer demand, persistent housing market sluggishness, and the absence of storm-driven sales catalysts. 

Storm-related categories—roofing, generators, emergency repair materials—typically provide a meaningful lift in Q3. This year, they didn't.

That's not a cyclical blip; it's a structural indicator of how sensitive Home Depot's earnings profile has become to external variables beyond core housing fundamentals.

The housing market remains the anchor. Elevated mortgage rates continue to suppress turnover, and affordability constraints are keeping homeowners on the sidelines for large remodeling projects. 

Big-ticket discretionary spending—the kitchen remodels, bathroom upgrades, outdoor projects that drive higher-margin sales—has stalled. Consumers are deferring, not canceling, but the timeline for that spending to return is extending further into 2026.

Gross and operating margins faced pressure from two sources: weaker transaction volume and the integration of lower-margin acquired businesses like GMS. 

The acquisition added revenue, but at the cost of margin compression. That's a trade-off management accepted to show top-line growth, but it doesn't solve the underlying demand problem.

Your dream retirement isn’t going to fund itself—that’s what your portfolio is for.

When generating income for a comfortable retirement, there are countless options to weigh. Muni bonds, dividends, REITs, Master Limited Partnerships—each comes with risk and oppor-tunity.

The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income from Fisher investments shows you ways you can position your portfolio to help you maintain or improve your lifestyle in retirement.

It also highlights common mistakes, such as tax mistakes, that can make a substantial differ-ence as you plan your well-deserved future.

Download your free copy today.

Home Depot is currently trading at a forward P/E of 24.34x. That's a premium multiple for a retailer with negative earnings growth, declining transaction volume, and exposure to a housing market that shows no signs of stabilization before Q2 2026 at the earliest. 

Wall Street's consensus price target sits at $429.33, implying modest upside from current levels, but that target assumes a demand recovery that management itself is no longer forecasting.

Stifel downgraded the stock to "Hold" following the report, and other analysts are reassessing their bullish stances. The debate now centers on whether this is a Home 

Depot-specific execution issue or a sector-wide structural problem. The data suggests it's the latter. Housing-driven demand weakness isn't unique to Home Depot—it's a macroeconomic constraint affecting the entire home improvement category.

If you hold exposure to retail or consumer discretionary ETFs, this report should prompt a reassessment. 

Home Depot is a top-10 holding in funds like the SPDR S&P Retail ETF $XRT and the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund $XLY.

A prolonged earnings recession at HD will weigh on those funds' performance, particularly if Lowe's reports similar weakness when it announces results later this week.

Housing-linked ETFs, funds with exposure to residential construction, building materials, and real estate, are also at risk. 

Home Depot's transaction volume decline signals that consumer engagement with home improvement is contracting, not stabilizing. 

That's a negative read-through for homebuilders, materials suppliers, and related equities.

Then there's the tariff question. 

The incoming administration has floated tariffs of up to 25% on Chinese imports starting Q1 2026. 

Home Depot sources a significant portion of its product mix from China—tools, hardware, building materials, appliances. 

If those tariffs are implemented, the company faces a binary choice: absorb the cost and compress margins further, or pass the cost to consumers and risk additional transaction volume declines.

Management didn't provide explicit guidance on tariff exposure during the earnings call, but investors should monitor any language around "pricing strategies" or "cost mitigation" in future commentary. 

Historical precedent from the 2018-2019 trade war suggests that tariffs on consumer goods create margin pressure in the short term and demand destruction in the medium term if retailers push prices higher.

Three data points matter most going forward: transaction volume trends, professional contractor activity, and any margin stabilization signals. 

If transaction volume continues to decline in Q4, it confirms that consumer engagement is deteriorating, not stabilizing. 

Professional contractor spending has held up better than retail, but that segment is also vulnerable if commercial construction activity slows.

Margin performance will determine whether Home Depot can defend its valuation multiple. If gross margins continue to compress due to integration costs and weaker volume, the forward P/E premium becomes untenable. Analysts are already modeling lower EPS for 2026, but if margins deteriorate faster than expected, those estimates will move lower.

Home Depot's Q3 report confirms what the housing data has been signaling for months: demand for big-ticket home improvement spending is weak, transaction volume is declining, and the recovery timeline is extending further into 2026. 

Management is executing well operationally, but they can't control the macro environment, and the macro environment isn't cooperating.

For investors with ETF exposure to retail, consumer discretionary, or housing-linked sectors, this report is a yellow flag, not a red one.

But if Lowe's reports similar weakness and Q4 transaction data doesn't improve, that yellow flag turns red. 

The valuation premium Home Depot commands assumes a recovery is imminent. The data suggests it's not.

What's catching investor attention today: The $16B AI Bet. Rivian's "False" Surge. The Pharma Squeeze

Disclaimer: This is not financial or investment advice. Do your own research and consult a qualified financial advisor before investing.